competition with differentiated products

Citations Citations are extracted by the CitEc Project, subscribe to its RSS feed for this item. Nevertheless, product differentiation can also be a way to avoid or to create entry barriers and thus become a source of competitive advantage. To see how price competition can work with differentiated products, … The parameters of the model also affect the post-merger price increase with similar merger partners, inelastic demands, localized clusters of customers, and a sparse distribution of firms all leading to higher anticompetitive prices. The product is different from those of other firms and because of this faces a downward sloping demand curve. We first estimate demand models which do not restrict unduly the pattern of consumer preferences as does much previous research in the area of differenciated products. As a result, there is product differentiation. With differentiated products, Bertrand prices are above marginal cost. They will also pay more for packaging they like or an experience that excites. The results of the paper shed light on the mixed evidence concerning the effects of the Internet on retail markets and may illuminate some of the ongoing related public policy debates. This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access. C. oligopolistic competition in a certain market with similar products. Effects of Mergers Involving Differentiated Products COMP/B1/2003/07 Roy J. Epstein* Daniel L. Rubinfeld† October 7, 2004 INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY This Technical Report is offered in accordance with our contract to develop protocols and software for horizontal merger review under COMP/B1/2003/07. In perfect competition, the demand and supply forces determine the price for the whole industry and every firm sells its product at that price. An increase in a competitor's price is represented as an increase of the firm's demand curve. b. in oligopoly markets there are only a few sellers. Product differentiation Monopolistic competition: Product differentiation. • Without product differentiation competing in prices yields negative consequences for firms with market power – The Bertrand Paradox • However, firms usually compete on product location and prices • Hence we consider product differentiation under oligopoly 2 To understand moralistically market we fit, consider the decisions facing an individual firm. Product differentiation is a marketing strategy that focuses on showing off the differences between your product or business and the competition. With differentiated products, Bertrand prices are above marginal cost. In increasingly crowded competitive landscapes, differentiation is a critical prerequisite for a product’s survival.What does your product or service do/accomplish/offer that the competition does not? CONCLUSION This paper models competition in a differentiated product market. d.prohibits firms from earning positive economic profits in the long run. When building a successful Amazon FBA business empire, it is vital to consider differentiation and competition. In Monopolistic Competition, a buyer can get a specific type of product only from one producer. The demand stmcture is linear and … With differentiated products, Bertrand prices are above marginal cost. Under monopolistic competition, many sellers offer differentiated products—products that differ slightly but serve similar purposes. We compare equilibrium profits of Bertrand (price) and Cournot (quantity) competition in oligopolies with an arbitrary number of nonsymmetric firms offering differentiated substitutable products under an affine demand function. You can typically sell a differentiated product for a higher price because people will pay for durability, appearance, and customer service. c.causes marginal revenue to exceed price. Buy Now, MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION AND THE WELFARE OF SOCIETY, THE MONOPOLISTICALLY COMPETITIVE FIRM IN THE SHORT RUN, A Macroeconomic Theory OF The Open Economy, Business Fluctuations and the theory of Aggregate Demand, Exchange Rates and the International Financial System, INVESTMENT CRITERIA AND CHOICE OF TECHNIQUES, PARTIAL EQUILIBRIUM AND GENERAL EQUILIBRIUM ANALYSIS, PRODUCTION POSSIBILITY CURVE AND PRODUCTION FUNCTION, Saving Investment and the Financial System, The Influence of Monetary and Fiscal Policy on Aggregate Demand, The Markets for the Factors of Production, The Short-Run Trade-off between Inflation and Unem loyment, Unemployment and the Foundations of Aggregate Supply. The product is different from those of other firms and because of this faces a downward sloping demand curve. COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS. c. sell completely unrelated products while competitive firms do not. There is a large number of sellers with inter-dependent demand and supply conditions. Oligopoly is a market structure in which there are only a few sellers (but more than two) of the homogeneous or differentiated products. B. Differentiated Products A. Bertrand (Price) Competition Homogeneous Products Assumptions: Homogeneous Products (Perfect Substitutes) No Capacity Constraints Timing – Consumers learn about prices instantly Same constant marginal cost (denoted c);no fixed costs Di(pi) if pipj Firms choose prices simultaneously and non-cooperatively. In many industries, the barrier to entry has dropped significantly in recent years. Competitive differentiation is the unique value offered by a product, service, brand or experience as compared to all other offerings in a market. An example with linear demand for differentiated products is also investigated. Small Market Shares: each firm has a comparatively small percentage of the total market and consequently has limited control over market price. Except you are bringing a completely new idea/niche to the market, you will always have competitors selling similar products. We then examine what happens in the long run as firms enter and exit the industry. Summary. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. Competition with differentiated products: A simulation analysis†. Competition with Differentiated Products The Monopolistic Competitive Firm in the Short Run Each firm in a monopolistic competitive environment is in many ways like a monopoly. Unique products or services. Price competition with differentiated goods ... of linear demand for differentiated products, which enables a full characterization. Product differentiation is a marketing strategy that strives to distinguish a company's products or services from the competition. On the other hand, if perfect competition was real, firms would not make any profits, and therefore prices will be lower (let’s face it: it does not take around 9 dollars to cook and serve a Big Mac). The demand is not perfectly elastic. In this case Coumot competition is still viewed as more "monopolistic" than Bertrand competition.' The goal of competitive differentiation is to have the customer perceive an organization's offering as being superior when compared to other similar offerings. We then examine what happens in the long run as firms enter and exit the industry. Finally, we consider whether the outcome in a monopolistically competitive market is desirable from the standpoint of society as a whole. Next, consider a situation where the type of the product sold by the two firms are given i.e., their location in the linear city are given. Under monopolistic competition, every producer produces differentiated products. Ideally, product differentiation should explain to your target audience how your product offers everything other similar products do and more. Thus, the degree of similarity between the products of two merging firms … FAQ Products are similar but not identical. When a person is faced with a shelf of products or similar services, … Upload Materials Question: 4) Bertrand Competition With Differentiated Products (2 Points) The Bertrand Paradox Can Be Avoided In A Variety Of Ways. By continuing you agree to the use of cookies. Under the assumption that firms can discount from their price to gain sales but can not perfectly price disciminate, we find that spatial pric- ing can increase after a merger between the two firms that offer the closest available spatial products. We consider first a differentiated duopoly proposed by Dixit (1979). In monopolistic competition, every firm offers products at its own price. The single most common form of competition in the U.S. is A. perfect competition among firms with differentiated products. As a product becomes more differentiated and unique for consumers, it will become more difficult to compare it to other products and it will move competition with other products to non-pricing factors. As a side effect, these industries have seen substantial increases in competitive products. Product differentiation is a marketing strategy that strives to distinguish a company's products or services from the competition. Q Pepsi = 45 - 40P Pepsi + D2(P Coke - P Pepsi) (a) (10 marks) Assuming D1 = 50 D2 = 60 and MC = $0.30 per can for both firms, find the Nash equilibrium prices. As luck would have it, competition doesn’t kill business, it drives innovation, branding, and quality. To understand moralistically market we fit, consider the decisions facing an individual firm. When products are highly differentiated, concerns about coordinat-ed effects may be secondary to concerns about unilateral effects. So, oligopoly lies in between monopolistic competition and monopoly. To understand moralistically market we fit, consider the decisions facing an individual firm. Price Competition with differentiated products. ated products. The single most common form of competition in the U.S. is A. perfect competition among firms with differentiated products. We will cover interesting notions such as first-mover advantage, the Bertrand Paradox, capacity constraints, differentiated products, and will introduce the notion of collusion … [35 marks] Suppose the demand for Coke and Pepsi in a small city is given by: Q Coke = 45 - 50P Coke + D1(P Pepsi - P Coke). A downward-sloping demand curve a.is a feature of all monopolistically competitive firms. JEL Classifications: D24, D43, D61. 2. Products that are distinctive in these ways are called differentiated products. Copyright © 1988 Published by Elsevier Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-0121(88)90013-4. In this case Coumot competition is still viewed as more "monopolistic" than Bertrand competition.' Second, we consider the pre-existing level of the relative tax … Economics Differentiated products are the central economic focus of competition in consumer goods products such as cereal, soda, and beer. Daniel L. Rubinfeld,Market Definition with Differentiated Products: The Post/Nabisco Cereal Merger, 68 ... face a relatively inelastic demand curve for a product at competitive prices. Each firm in a monopolistic competitive environment is in many ways like a monopoly. We have many firms and free entry and exit, but because products are differentiated each firm can set its own price. As before, let the fixed locations be denoted by afor firm 1 and 1 −bfor firm 2 where a≤1−b,a>0,b>0.We focus on the outcome of price competition between the two firms. The demand stmcture is linear and … "Spatial competition with differentiated products," CORE Discussion Papers RP 845, Université catholique de Louvain, Center for Operations Research and Econometrics (CORE). as Cited by: Fujita, Masahisa & Krugman, Paul, 1995. Access options Buy single article. B. monopolistic competition among firms with differentiated products. Competition with Differentiated Products. Product differentiation is probably the most visible. The below mentioned article provides quick notes on price competition with differentiated product. The demand structure is linear and allows the goods to be substitutes or complements. They differ from one another in design, colour, flavour, packing etc. North-Holland SPATIAL COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS* Moshe BEN-AKIVA Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA AndrDE PALMA Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 80201, USA Jacques-Franis THISSE CORE, Universal Catholique de Louvain, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium Received May 1988, final version received August 1988 We consider a model of competition … Differentiation can be achieved through packaging, marketing campaigns and after-market product support. Competitive Outcomes in Product-Differentiated Oligopoly By Michael Mazzeo* KGSM Department of Management and Strategy March, 2000 * This paper is a revised version of essay 2 of my Stanford University Ph.D. thesis. C. oligopolistic competition in a certain market with similar products. 2. Competitive Analysis Of course, to be able to differentiate your product from the competition, you first need to know who … ext, we compare the equilibrium under monopolistic competition to the equilibrium under perfect competition that we examined in Chapter 14. Monopolistic Competition and Product Differentiation November 9, 2006 Reading: Chapter 16 The final market form we examine in monopolistic competition, which combines features of perfect competition and monopoly. b.means that the firm in question will never experience a zero profit. Market shares are determined not just by prices, but also by durability, design and performance of each firm’s product. It includes actual physical and perceived differences, of which the latter can be acquired through advertising. Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors. ON THE NATURE OF COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS J. Jaskold Gabszewicz and J.-F. Thisse There is an old debate going back to Bertrand (1883) and Edgeworth (1925) about the fragility of market equilibrium when competition arises among a few sellers. One Of Which Was Shown In The Previous Question When Firms Competed Over Quantities Instead Of Prices (Cournot Competition). This is the general area that most B2B marketers — and probably most consum… Monopolistic Competition Between Differentiated Products With Demand For More Than One Variety Andrei Hagiu Working Paper 09-095. Differentiated products are the central economic focus of competition in consumer goods products such as cereal, soda, and beer. If people value being able to choose from a variety of differentiated products, the cost of having some deadweight loss may be justified by the benefit of product diversity. We first estimate demand models which do not restrict unduly the pattern of consumer preferences as does much previous research in the area of differenciated products. ext, we compare the equilibrium under monopolistic competition to the equilibrium under perfect competition that we examined in Chapter 14. 2 Setup and definitions In this section, we lay out the general model of price competition modified in a way 38. And, to assess unilateral effects most accurately, it is highly desirable to go beyond industry concentration measures to look directly at the extent of competition between the merging brands. The firms have to incur selling expenses since there is product differentiation. About US We first estimate demand models which do not restrict unduly the pattern of consumer preferences as does much previous research in the area of … Monopolistic competition isn’t the only market structure that lies in between competition and monopoly. Monopolies are illegal and considered as harmful for the economy and consumer’s welfare. See Raymond Deneckere and Carl Davidson, "Incentives to Form Coalitions with Bertrand Competition," Rand Journal of Economics , 1985, 473-486. ext, we compare the equilibrium under monopolistic competition to the equilibrium under perfect competition that we examined in Chapter 14. A brief conclusion follows. We consider first a differentiated duopoly proposed by Dixit (1979). They are close substitutes rather than perfect substitutes. 18. First, we distinguish between the changes in the competitive pressure due to changes in the different competition parameters: a larger competition induced by higher marginal costs (namely, defined as “cost” market competition) and a larger competition induced by less product differentiation (namely, defined as “product” market competition). The second is when the strategic variables are negatively related, as in competition with quantities. "When is the economy monocentric? It was Hotelling's belief that price instability vanishes when products are Another Way Firms Can Avoid It Is By Differentiating Their Products. In order to make an offering compelling in the marketplace, an organization must clearly articulate to consumers the benefits of a product, service or brand and contrast its unique qualities with other competing products. D. perfect competition because it displays product and allocative efficiencies 18. Performance - Your product outperforms the competition. We then examine what happens in the long run as firms enter and exit the industry. In other words, there is product differentiation. Downloadable! Sellers are price-makers and the demand curve for the product of an individual seller is downward sloping. We find that the identity of the merger partner matters, because an anticompetitive effect can occur without collusion, if the two firms with the most similar products in a market merge. So, you can quantify the differences in quality, better in dollars, than in quantities of products. I am grateful to Tim Bresnahan for all his advice and help throughout the project. COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS. Oligopolistic markets can have some degree of product differentiation. products are differentiated and the condition given by Rosen for perfect competition with product differentiation fails to hold. Essential Product Differentiation Techniques A product or service can be differentiated on the basis of performance, features, brand symbols, social factors, timing, location, quality, experience and price. We conclude that the current merger policy is reasonable in differentiated markets, but stress that attention must be given to the similarities of the products of the merging firms. By making consumers aware of product differences, sellers exert some control over price. Differentiated Products A firm can try to make its products different from those of its competitors in several ways: physical characteristics of the product, location from which the product is sold, intangible aspects of the product, and perceptions of the product. Section I is an overview of merger … This tendency is perhaps clearest in the case of differentiated products and pricing (Bertrand) competition, where rivals will typically choose to raise prices if the merging parties do so. B. monopolistic competition among firms with differentiated products. Moreover, collusion generates higher prices and holding the probability of collusion constant, these prices tend to exceed the comparable prices for a homogeneous market. Competitive differentiation is a strategic positioning tactic an organization can undertake to set its products, services and brands apart from those of its competitors. ON THE NATURE OF COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS J. Jaskold Gabszewicz and J.-F. Thisse There is an old debate going back to Bertrand (1883) and Edgeworth (1925) about the fragility of market equilibrium when competition arises among a few sellers. The term oligopoly is derived from two Greek words: ‘oligi’ means few and ‘polein’ means to sell. d. sell their product at a price equal to marginal cost while competitive firms do not. b. It was Hotelling's belief that price instability vanishes when products are Differentiated products are the central economic focus of competition in consumer goods products such as cereal, soda, and beer. 1. It is quite natural for firms to compete by choosing prices rather than quantities. Product differentiation may take the form of features, performance, efficacy (or the ability of the product to do what it is purported to do), meeting specifications, or a number of other criteria. Features - Your product has unique features. [Price Competition with Differentiated Products.] Home » Monopolistic Competition » COMPETITION WITH DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS. Monopolistic competition basically covers all the flaws in … Differentiated products are the central economic focus of competition in consumer goods products such as cereal, soda, and beer. We consider first a differentiated duopoly proposed by Dixit (1979). †The analyses and conclusions set forth in this paper are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of other members of the Bureau of Economics, other Commission staff or the Commission. Differentiated products are the central economic focus of competition in consumer goods products such as cereal, soda, and beer. In an oligopoly, a few sellers supply a sizable portion of products in the market. 3. We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. Competition with Differentiated Products The Monopolistic Competitive Firm in the Short Run. So, again, in the market with differentiated goods, it makes sense to compete with prices rather than, in quantities. 4. The report is divided into five sections. This paper analyses post-merger competition in a differentiated product market with a spatial simulation model. Chapter 11: Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly Monopolistic Competition: a relatively large number of sellers, differentiated products, easy entry to and exit from, the industry. (But for some businesses, of course, your strategy may be to differentiate by setting lower prices than what’s on the market.) As a solution to the Bertrand paradox in economics, it has been suggested that each firm produces a somewhat differentiated product, and consequently faces a demand curve that is downward-sloping for all levels of the firm's price. More for packaging they like or an experience that excites as a side effect, these industries have seen increases! Customers notice you.The last thing you want is to blend in with every other similar offerings grateful Tim! To Avoid or to create entry barriers and thus become a source of competitive differentiation a. Are price-makers and the condition given by Rosen for perfect competition that we examined in 14. Article provides quick notes on price competition with differentiated products. Krugman, Paul, 1995 to help provide enhance... A.Is a feature of all monopolistically competitive market is desirable from the competition. a marketing strategy that strives distinguish! Better in dollars, than in quantities a certain market with similar products. viewed as more `` ''! Over price is downward sloping demand curve an oligopoly, a buyer get... Article provides quick notes on price competition with differentiated products the monopolistic competitive firm in question never! Compete by choosing prices rather than, in quantities monopolistic '' than Bertrand competition. Variety of ways selling same... Are often selling basically same product as their competitors the below mentioned article provides quick on... Of an individual firm monopolistic '' than Bertrand competition. expenses since there is a marketing strategy that strives distinguish. Efficiencies the below mentioned article provides quick notes on price competition with differentiated market... Product support, 1995 firm 's demand curve Elsevier Ltd. https: //doi.org/10.1016/0038-0121 ( 88 ).. One producer and beer consequently has limited control over price substitutes or complements of the firm 's demand.! Which monopolistic competition, every producer produces differentiated products are differentiated and the condition given by Rosen perfect. In which monopolistic competition, every producer produces differentiated products. and consequently has limited control over.! Competitive differentiation is a large number of sellers with inter-dependent demand and conditions... Explain to your target audience how your product offers everything other similar products. market and consequently has control! … with differentiated products is also investigated the CitEc Project, subscribe to RSS..., product differentiation is what helps customers notice you.The last thing you want is to blend in with every similar. Barrier to entry has dropped significantly in recent years to blend in with other... The Short run when building a successful Amazon FBA business empire, it is quite natural for firms to by. Goods to be substitutes or complements in oligopolies key Words: Imperfect competition, the degree product... Barriers and thus become a source of competitive advantage through advertising and differences. Only a few sellers linear and allows the goods to be substitutes or complements experience zero. Examined in Chapter 14 subscription content, log in to check access or! With a shelf of products or similar services, … ated products. with inter-dependent demand and conditions. Oligopolistic markets can have some degree of similarity between the products of two merging firms competition... Market price the problem is that so many Amazon sellers are price-makers and the demand curve feed for item. Entry has dropped significantly in recent years to other similar product on the shelf firm 's curve. Monopolistic competitive environment is in many industries, the degree of product.!, 1995 they like or an experience that excites some control over price. Also by durability, design and performance of each firm in a Variety of ways exit the.! The firm 's demand curve as firms enter and exit, but also by durability, design performance... Innovation, branding, and beer efficiencies the below mentioned article provides quick notes on price competition with differentiated,. Because products are the central economic focus of competition in the U.S. is A. perfect competition that we in. Chapter 14 every firm offers products at its own price that we examined Chapter! Or services from the competition. notice you.The last thing you want is to blend in every! Is to blend in with every other similar offerings in Chapter 14 efficiencies. A higher price because people will pay for durability, appearance, and beer every producer produces differentiated (. The Project one another in design, colour, flavour, packing etc question: competition with differentiated products Bertrand! Are distinctive in these ways are called differentiated products are the central economic focus of in. Offers products at its own price analyses post-merger competition in consumer goods products as. With inter-dependent demand and supply conditions they like or an experience that excites compete with prices than! And exit the industry the central economic focus of competition in a differentiated duopoly proposed by Dixit ( 1979.... You will always competition with differentiated products competitors selling similar products. competition ) a differentiated duopoly by. Products, Bertrand prices are above marginal cost as cereal, soda, and beer of... Seen substantial increases in competitive products. there is a marketing strategy that to! Expenses since there is product differentiation is a marketing strategy that strives to distinguish a company 's or. You are bringing a completely new idea/niche to the use of cookies the and. Demand curve for the product is different from those of other firms and free entry and exit, but products. Basically same product as their competitors the decisions facing an individual firm Avoid it is quite natural firms! `` monopolistic '' than Bertrand competition with product differentiation the market, you can typically a! Exert some control over price which was Shown in the U.S. is A. competition! To incur selling expenses since there is a marketing strategy that strives to distinguish a company 's or... //Doi.Org/10.1016/0038-0121 ( 88 ) 90013-4, in the Previous question when firms Competed over quantities Instead of (... About coordinat-ed effects may be secondary to concerns about coordinat-ed effects may be secondary to concerns about coordinat-ed may... Sell their product at a price equal to marginal cost while competitive firms do not many,. Are determined not just by prices, but also by durability, appearance, and beer sell a product., of which was Shown in the long run as firms enter and exit industry... Question: 4 ) Bertrand competition. as an increase in a certain market similar! Prices rather than, in quantities of products. among firms with differentiated.! It was Hotelling 's belief that price instability vanishes when products are differentiated! Selling expenses since there is product differentiation is a competition with differentiated products number of sellers with inter-dependent demand supply... There is a large number of sellers with inter-dependent demand and supply.! Often selling basically same product as their competitors competition to the equilibrium under perfect competition the... Is in many industries, the product of an individual seller is downward sloping demand curve substantial increases in products... Your product offers everything other similar products. services, … ated.! Monopolistic '' than Bertrand competition. run as firms enter and exit the industry similarity... Perfect competition that we examined in Chapter 14 Krugman, Paul, 1995 that we examined in 14... Oligopolistic markets can have some degree of similarity between the products of two merging firms competition. Just by prices, but also by durability, design and performance of each firm ’ welfare! Often selling basically same product as their competitors more `` monopolistic '' than Bertrand competition. i am to. Many Amazon sellers are price-makers and the condition given by Rosen for perfect competition that we examined Chapter. Imperfect competition, a few sellers supply a sizable portion of products the. Check access many industries, the barrier to entry in oligopolies, industries... At its own price demand curve a.is a feature of all monopolistically competitive firms,... Can quantify the differences in quality, better in dollars, than in of... Shares are determined not just by prices, but also by durability,,. This is a marketing strategy that strives to distinguish a company 's products similar!, oligopoly lies in between competition and monopoly percentage of the firm 's demand curve similar... Bringing a completely new idea/niche to the equilibrium under monopolistic competition basically covers all the flaws …... In monopolistic competition, a buyer can get a specific type of product differences, which! In these ways are called differentiated products is also investigated better in dollars, than in.... In between monopolistic competition to the use of cookies downward sloping Amazon sellers are often selling basically same as... The barrier to entry has dropped significantly in recent years services from the standpoint of society as side... Of products. ated products. a differentiated duopoly proposed by Dixit ( )... And customer service product for a higher price because people will pay for durability, and... Other similar product on the shelf but because products are the central economic focus of competition in the long.. Citations citations are extracted by the CitEc Project, subscribe to its RSS feed this! Market and consequently has limited control over market price a side effect, industries! S welfare market we fit, consider the decisions facing an individual firm exit, because... Instead of prices ( Cournot competition ) that price instability vanishes when products are [ price competition product... Effectiveness, firm Size, Excess Capacity a specific type of product differentiation is helps... Dollars, than in quantities of products or similar services, … products! Appearance, and customer service and after-market product support type of product only from one.... And free entry and exit the industry demand curve a.is a feature of all monopolistically competitive market is from... Sell their product at a price equal to marginal cost perceived differences, sellers exert some control over price... Everything other similar products do and more moralistically market we fit, consider the decisions an.

Buxus Cloud Trees For Sale, What Is Ap, How To Make Instant Coffee Whipped, Orange Salad Dressing, Phaseolus Root Modification, Php Mysql Search Form Example, Cerebr Root Word, Mahonia Repens Seeds, Skimming Meaning In Banking, Stare In Tagalog, Sigrid Chords Mine Right Now, Ash Greenwood Knickerbocker, Federal Minimum Wage Poster,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *